top of page

Beyond Consent: Teaching Children the Freedom to Say No

Mark Neugebauer - FCP Australia
30 minutes ago
22 min read

The moral boundary: chastity, self-restraint, marriage and what adults owe children beyond the mechanics of permission.


FCP AUSTRALIA | INVESTIGATIVE SERIES | PART 2 OF 6

Protecting Childhood - Consent, Culture and the Institutions Shaping Our Children

The second in a six-part investigation examining the laws protecting children, the ideas challenging those boundaries, and the institutions responsible for safeguarding them.


In this investigation




The question the law cannot answer


In the first article of this investigation, I examined historical and contemporary arguments challenging the laws that protect children from sexual contact with adults. The law cannot leave those boundaries to a child's apparent willingness. Children have a dignity that does not depend upon convincing an adult, a court or an institution that they resisted sufficiently.


That inquiry ended with a different question. If the law must protect children from exploitation, what should adults be teaching them before those legal boundaries are ever tested?


I ask that as a father and grandfather, and as a Christian. The moral convictions I bring to this subject are not hidden. I believe that sexual intimacy belongs within faithful marriage between a man and a woman, and that chastity, modesty, patience and self-restraint are virtues worth cultivating. I also know that believing those things does not place Christians above temptation or failure. We need repentance, prayer and discipline precisely because we are not immune from our own weaknesses and past failings.


I believe there are two freedoms children need to learn. The first is the freedom to say no when another person makes an unwanted request. The second may be exercised long before there is anyone else making a request: the freedom to say no to our own desires. It may involve resisting pressure, turning away from pornography or choosing not to become sexually active simply because we could. The first freedom is essential to protection. The second belongs to the formation of character.


Consent asks whether an act can take place freely and without coercion. Chastity asks what intimacy is for, what love requires and when choosing not to act may itself be good. These are not rival questions. My concern is whether our public conversation explains the first with confidence while becoming less able to commend the second.

That distinction, between permission and purpose, is the question I want to follow through this investigation.



What James and Joanna Howe were challenging


In a September 2026 conversation on episode 273 of The Dr Jo Show, James and Joanna Howe questioned whether repeated appeals to better consent education can adequately address the consequences of a culture accustomed to casual sexual relationships. Their concern went beyond whether people understand the rules of consent. They were asking what young people are being taught about character, restraint, commitment and the purpose of sexual intimacy. They pointed towards faithful marriage as a relationship grounded in mutual responsibility, patience and self-giving, rather than negotiated permission alone.


James's remark, “I don't do consent,” became the most widely circulated part of the conversation. Having examined the fuller exchange, I recognise that his criticism was not confined to that one sentence. He repeatedly questioned the value of consent education, at one point declaring that marriage works while consent does not.


I believe some of that language could have been more measured. The personal remarks directed at Chanel Contos detracted from the message, and certain comments about sexual pressure deserved greater care. Consent remains essential, including within marriage. A faithful covenant does not remove either spouse's freedom to refuse intimacy, nor does it excuse coercion. Those principles should never be treated as negotiable.


John Sandeman, writing in The Other Cheek, published a longer excerpt of the conversation and concluded that it did not justify portraying the Howes as advocates of marital rape. The Howes subsequently offered their own explanation. I believe the fuller context matters, not because every remark should be defended, but because the underlying question deserves consideration on its merits.


What resonated with me was something more fundamental about how we approach the education of children. Listening to the exchange, I found myself wondering whether we have allowed the language of consent to become the starting point for conversations that ought to begin somewhere else.


What if, instead of beginning with “teaching consent”, we began with “teaching children to say no”?


I am not suggesting that James explicitly proposed those words. They are how I have come to understand the deeper concern raised by the discussion. The distinction is important. Teaching consent necessarily involves explaining when agreement is freely given, how to recognise coercion and why another person's refusal must be respected. These are essential protections, and I would not remove them.


But teaching children to say no can begin before anyone seeks their agreement. It can teach them that they are under no obligation to become sexually active, that attraction does not require action, and that neither curiosity nor opportunity makes something wise or good. It can also teach children to govern their own desires, to refrain from making inappropriate requests of others, and to recognise that waiting may itself be an expression of maturity, dignity and love.


This is where I believe the Howes' emphasis on chastity, character and faithful marriage has something important to contribute. The question is not only whether intimacy can be freely agreed to, but whether sexual intimacy itself ought to be reserved for a faithful, lifelong commitment.


Chanel Contos founded Teach Us Consent after young people disclosed experiences of sexual assault, and the organisation's stated purpose is to prevent sexual violence. That is a serious and necessary concern. Children must understand bodily boundaries, recognise inappropriate behaviour, know they can refuse unwanted contact and feel confident seeking help from trusted adults. Their protection must never depend upon whether they were sufficiently assertive or managed to say no. Responsibility for coercion or assault rests with the person who commits it.


I do not regard these protective responsibilities as incompatible with teaching chastity and restraint. Rather, I wonder whether we have given one part of the conversation considerably more attention than another. We rightly explain why sexual activity without consent is unacceptable. Are we equally willing to explain why young people may choose not to pursue sexual activity at all, even where agreement might otherwise be possible?


That, for me, is the distinction between permission and purpose. Consent education addresses necessary boundaries. A positive account of chastity asks what sexual intimacy is for, what love requires and why self-restraint may be good for both ourselves and others. Both questions matter, but answering the first does not necessarily answer the second.


The concern is not confined to the Howes. In Rethinking Sex, American writer Christine Emba argues that consent provides a necessary ethical starting point but cannot answer every question about intimacy, responsibility and another person's good. In a 2022 conversation at the California Institute of Integral Studies, Emba described consent as a floor rather than a ceiling. Her Catholic convictions inform her perspective, but the distinction she draws can be considered by readers who do not share them.


I share the underlying Christian conviction that chastity, fidelity and restraint are not merely prohibitions. They can be positive ways of respecting ourselves and loving another person. And I believe children deserve to hear that message clearly, long before they are confronted with decisions for which they may not yet be ready.



What consent education gets right, and what it leaves open


I want to be clear about what must remain in place. Australia's National Office for Child Safety teaches children that they may refuse unwanted touching, change their minds and seek help from safe adults. It also explains that children cannot consent to sexual activity with adults, regardless of apparent agreement. These are essential safeguards. Teaching chastity and marriage as positive goods does not require weakening them; it requires asking what else children should be taught alongside them.


In South Australia, the legal meaning of sexual consent involves free and voluntary agreement. The Legal Services Commission's explanation of sections 46 and 48 makes clear that agreement can be absent or withdrawn and that continuing sexual intercourse without consent can constitute rape. Those protections apply within marriage as well as outside it. The law is not a complete guide to love, but it is an essential safeguard against coercion.


Consent education can help young people recognise manipulation, pressure, intoxication, silence, a change of mind and situations in which a person feels unable to speak. It can teach boys and girls alike to accept rejection without resentment, which is itself an exercise in self-restraint. None of this requires treating sexual activity as an inevitable part of adolescence.


Readiness is also worth examining separately from legal permission. A 2019 analysis of the British Natsal-3 survey considered the first heterosexual intercourse reported by sexually experienced 17-to-24-year-olds. It found that 39.7 per cent of women and 26.5 per cent of men did not consider it to have occurred at the right time. The researchers assessed willingness, independence from pressure, reliable contraception and perceived timing as separate dimensions. That finding does not mean all those respondents had freely consented and then regretted it; some reported pressure or unequal willingness. It does show why knowing the rules of consent cannot settle every question of readiness and judgment.


The evidence, however, is not simple enough to claim that attending a workshop necessarily changes subsequent conduct. An October 2026 systematic review of eighteen randomised trials of school-based sexual-violence prevention found improvements in knowledge and attitudes, but less frequent or more limited evidence of behavioural change. The authors also identified short follow-up periods and participant attrition. That is a reason to assess these programmes rigorously, not to dismiss the value of their protective messages.


I want children to know that they may say no to unwanted touch, and that another person's no must always be respected. I also want them to hear, without embarrassment, that they may decline sexual activity itself because they believe waiting is good. How often is that latter choice commended as a positive expression of maturity, rather than simply mentioned as an option among many?


Waiting is not an imaginary path. The eighth Australian Survey of Secondary Students and Sexual Health, reporting data collected in 2024–25, included 4,396 young people aged fourteen to eighteen. Half of those surveyed reported no experience of oral, vaginal or anal sex. Among the 2,178 respondents asked why they had not yet had sex, 39 per cent said they were not ready, 37 per cent wanted to be in love and 15 per cent identified waiting until marriage. Respondents could give several reasons. The survey used non-probability recruitment and is not statistically representative of all Australian adolescents, but it gives these young people's choices a voice in a debate that sometimes assumes adolescence necessarily leads to sexual activity.


Those responses need to be read carefully. Among respondents who had not been sexually active, 58 per cent cited having no partner and 45 per cent a lack of opportunity. Others gave reasons involving readiness, love or marriage. I would not suggest that everyone who has not had sex has consciously chosen chastity. But neither should young people who choose to wait be regarded simply as those who have yet to do something expected of them. Waiting can itself be a considered decision.


The same survey also asked young people, in an optional open-text question, about the messages they had received from parents concerning sex and relationships. Of the 751 who responded, 208, or 28 per cent, described parental messages emphasising abstinence in some form, including waiting until they were older or married. These responses cannot represent every Australian family, but they show that the positive teaching of restraint remains part of contemporary family life.


If a fourteen-year-old chooses not to become sexually active, should that decision simply be respected, or should our society also be confident enough to affirm the patience, self-respect and restraint that may lie behind it?



When education teaches more than facts


This question becomes sharper when we examine the documents guiding Australian education. In March 2026, the Commonwealth released its National Respectful Relationships Education Framework, designed to support age-appropriate and evidence-informed teaching. Its stated objective includes preventing violence, developing respectful relationships and supporting school communities. We should take that purpose seriously.


I searched the National Respectful Relationships Education Framework for abstinence, chastity, postpone, delay, wait, marriage and fidelity. Abstinence, chastity, postpone, delay and fidelity did not appear. The word wait appeared in the title of the Consent Can’t Wait campaign, while marriage appeared in a listing for support concerning forced marriage. I could not find an affirmative recommendation to teach postponement or reserving sexual intimacy for marriage as positive educational objectives.


That is a finding about this national guidance document, not what every Australian classroom teaches. The Framework also directs schools to other resources and calls for engagement with parents and carers.


What interested me most was an earlier, government-funded research and consultation report prepared by researchers from Monash University, Deakin University and the University of Queensland. On page 24, the report argues that legal definitions of consent alone are insufficient. It recommends an ethics-informed approach that considers relationships, responsibilities, care for others, communication and power. In one respect, then, its authors recognise precisely the problem of reducing sexual conduct to legal permission.


One passage, however, gave me pause. Quoting researcher Dr Claire Stonehouse, who was also part of the report's project team, the authors refer to children's growing need to “build and develop their sexual subjectivities”. I recognise that this is academic language concerning how young people understand themselves in relation to sexuality. But I question the assumptions beneath it. At what age, and according to whose understanding of childhood, should schools be helping to shape a child's developing sexual identity? And how does that approach accommodate parents who believe that chastity, modesty and reserving sexual intimacy for marriage are themselves essential parts of a child's moral formation?


The question becomes not whether schools have an ethic, but which ethic they are teaching. An approach grounded in personal autonomy, negotiation and care will have points of agreement with Christian teaching. Respect for another person's dignity, attentiveness to unequal power and the duty to avoid harm should not be dismissed because they are expressed in secular language. Yet the Christian account of chastity asks a further question about the proper purpose of sexual intimacy and the place of lifelong fidelity. That difference cannot simply be resolved by better communication.


The same consultation report, on pages 71–72, records concern about the position of parents. In one workshop an education participant described schools as teaching facts while families could add their own values. Another acknowledged that some parents were anxious about discussion of sex before marriage. The authors also recognised parents as children's first educators and described parental engagement as underdeveloped. These were views expressed by participants, not a finding that every Australian school rejects parental convictions.


I struggle with the suggestion that facts and values can be separated so neatly. Reproductive biology can describe what occurs. But deciding which relationships, behaviours and outcomes are presented as desirable involves an ethical choice. What a document positively encourages matters; so can what it leaves unstated. The national Framework's silence about positively teaching chastity is therefore worth examining, though it cannot tell us what every teacher says in the classroom.


Consider the Australian Government’s Commonwealth Consent Policy Framework: Promoting healthy sexual relationships and consent among young people, published in January 2024. Of its ten principles of sexual consent, principle four is titled ‘Balance a positive focus on pleasure with risks.’ It asks organisations to balance positive discussion of healthy, pleasurable sexual activities and relationships with advice about risks and conduct to avoid. The stated aim includes preventing sexual violence through age-appropriate communication. Yet that emphasis is not morally neutral: it offers a positive account of sexual expression where freely chosen, without offering a comparable marriage-centred account of restraint.


The Commonwealth’s May 2024 media reporting guidelines for the Consent Can’t Wait campaign make a similar distinction. Written for journalists rather than classroom teachers, they explain that understanding consent is about more than avoiding unlawful conduct; sexual activity should also be positive and pleasurable for those involved. The guidance also emphasises empathy, respect and reducing sexual harm. It is a fair and legitimate concern. Yet it leaves me asking whether the virtues of patience, abstinence and reserving intimacy for marriage are given a similarly positive voice in our public guidance.


That is a genuine difference in moral outlook. We should neither hide it behind the word 'facts' nor turn it into an allegation that everyone working in education wishes to undermine families. Parents should be able to examine the actual material, understand what age group it is intended for, and ask whose ethical assumptions have been built into it.


South Australia's respectful relationships guidance states that its whole-school approach is being developed without introducing a new curriculum and that parents and carers were consulted. We should not confuse a national framework with what any particular teacher has delivered. What I can say at this stage is narrower and, I think, significant: the Commonwealth's published guidance makes some ethical commitments explicit and leaves others, including a positive account of chastity and marital fidelity, largely unexpressed. Which messages reach children in practice belongs to the next article.



When children encounter an adult sexual culture


The moral problem is not confined to classrooms. By the time many children receive formal lessons about sex, they have already encountered a world of sexualised images, conversations and online material. Pornography may be encountered accidentally, sent by peers or deliberately sought out. The exposure itself may come before meaningful conversations at home.


In a nationally representative eSafety survey conducted in late 2024 and early 2025, 32 per cent of Australian children aged ten to seventeen reported having seen sexual images or videos online; 12 per cent reported violent sexual images or videos. That measure is broader than pornography alone, and the figures should not be treated as a count of compulsive pornography users.


In a different eSafety study of 1,004 Australians aged sixteen to eighteen, 74.8 per cent reported having encountered online pornography at some point. Among those exposed, 39.1 per cent reported that their first encounter occurred before thirteen; about four in ten said their first encounter was accidental. The survey measures retrospective reports within an older adolescent group and cannot be directly compared with the younger-child survey as though the samples described one continuous trend.


A 2024 Australian study of 1,985 young people aged fifteen to twenty, by Maree Crabbe, Michael Flood and Kelsey Adams, found exposure reported by 86 per cent of male respondents and 69 per cent of female respondents. On average, exposure occurred years before respondents' first partnered sexual experiences. These numbers do not show that any particular child later acted upon what was seen. They do show why it is unrealistic to assume that young people learn about intimacy only when parents or schools decide the time is right.


I also examined the Australian Institute of Family Studies' September 2026 evidence review concerning pornography and young people. It identifies associations involving sexual attitudes, expectations and potentially harmful behaviour, while emphasising inconsistent measures, limited intervention studies and the inability to establish simple causal accounts. The report concludes that research is not sufficient to determine which educational responses best prevent potential harms. I do not want to weaken that finding by overstating the science.


This is where the question of purpose becomes practical. Children can encounter scripts that present intimacy as novelty, performance, dominance or gratification before any adult has discussed what makes a relationship good. Consent education can still teach them how to refuse coercion. It cannot, by itself, counter every expectation formed through commercial sexual material or explain why waiting may be an act of respect for oneself and another. That is not a claim that exposure causes identical harms in every child. It is a question about who is shaping desire, and what adults are willing to offer in response.


South Australia's own Parenting SA guidance warns that pornography can influence expectations, portray aggression or domination as ordinary, and crowd out affection, respect and relationships. The guidance encourages parents to ask what messages young people are receiving rather than simply branding the material good or bad. I understand why an approachable conversation matters. But I also believe a parent can be clear: something may be readily available and culturally accepted without being good for us.


One question keeps returning to me. If we would be concerned about a husband repeatedly comparing his wife with performers online, or a wife finding herself measuring her husband against unrealistic portrayals, why would we be casual about younger people encountering those same scripts before they have developed their understanding of intimacy? The research on adult relationships is mixed, but it includes accounts of pressure, secrecy, comparison and loss of intimacy.


A qualitative systematic review records some women describing unwanted pressure to imitate pornography alongside others reporting perceived benefits; a couples study found that solitary use hidden from a partner was associated with lower same-day relationship satisfaction and intimacy. These studies do not establish that every couple is harmed, but they make the relational questions concrete.


Pornography is not marriage, and intimacy is not a performance to be measured against the novelty of material designed to stimulate viewers. That is my moral conviction, informed by Christian teaching. It stands separately from whether a particular neurological theory or addiction model ultimately withstands scientific scrutiny.



When sexual harm occurs between children


Safeguarding does not concern only adults who exploit children. The Australian Child Maltreatment Study, drawing on a nationally representative survey of 8,503 people aged sixteen and over, found that 10.0 per cent of respondents reported childhood sexual abuse by another known adolescent who was not a current or former romantic partner. This is a proportion of people reporting that experience, not a claim that adolescents accounted for 10 per cent of all perpetrators. The study also found greater reported adolescent-perpetrated abuse among its younger respondents. Childhood sexual harm between peers is not hypothetical.


Those findings do not show that pornography caused any particular incident. Nor do they justify treating a child who displays harmful sexual behaviour as though that child necessarily has the intentions or responsibility of an adult offender. Children may themselves have been exposed to harmful material or experienced abuse. They require protection, careful assessment and responses appropriate to their development and circumstances.


The National Office for Child Safety recognises the need for developmentally informed responses to harmful sexual behaviour among children. That responsibility cannot be discharged by asking whether two children appeared to agree. Adults must consider age, development, power, pressure, understanding and the safety of all those involved. The study authors themselves argue for stronger protective and preventative education, including comprehensive relationships and sexuality education. I agree that safeguarding instruction is necessary; I am asking what positive moral formation should stand alongside it.


The underlying question remains: do children learn only to negotiate or refuse a request, or do they also learn that some requests are inappropriate to make, however willing another person may appear? Are they taught patience, privacy and respect for the dignity of another person, and do they know they can approach an adult without fear or shame?


I do not want children frightened of their bodies or made responsible for adults' failures to protect them. I want age-appropriate information, accessible help and an affirmative account of restraint. Protection cannot begin only after harm has occurred.



What research measures and what it misses


I have tried not to treat a finding as reliable merely because it appears in a respected journal or supports a position I already hold. The same questions apply to research favourable to comprehensive education and to studies promoting sexual-risk avoidance: who was studied, what was compared, what outcomes were chosen, and how long were they observed? A short-term gain in knowledge or a reported delay in sexual activity is worth knowing about, but it cannot by itself settle the deeper question of character.


One 2024 randomised study of the Relationships Under Construction programme, a sexual-risk-avoidance approach delivered through twelve American schools, reported reductions in sexual activity and pornography viewing and improvement in attitudes about delayed gratification at a three-month follow-up. That is relevant evidence that teaching restraint can have measurable short-term benefits. But the study also reported differences between intervention and control groups at baseline and called for research in more diverse populations. It cannot establish a lifetime effect on fidelity or marriage.


On the other side, the 2024 meta-analysis of forty-seven sexuality-education studies found improvements across several measures, including knowledge and some abstinence-related outcomes. Heterogeneity was high. A finding about contraceptive knowledge, intention or reported postponement does not automatically answer the broader question of what a child comes to believe about love, responsibility or lifelong commitment.


The United States Government Accountability Office's February 2026 review of sexual-risk-avoidance education identified mixed effectiveness evidence and weaknesses in government assessment of programme outcomes. A programme can be popular, widely delivered or accurately described as medically informed without there being strong evidence of lasting behavioural benefits. That caution applies across educational philosophies.


The studies answer the questions their investigators set out to measure. Knowledge about consent, recognition of coercion, sexual initiation, contraceptive intention and infection risk are important outcomes, but they do not amount to a complete account of moral formation. Some research does examine postponement and reasons for waiting; the Australian student survey itself does. Much less is established about whether a particular programme nurtures enduring patience, faithful commitment or a willingness to resist cultural pressure.


That leaves a question which cannot be answered by counting workshops delivered or favourable attitudes recorded shortly afterwards. Are children developing the freedom to say no to another person's demands and the freedom to govern their own desires? Those are different capacities, though each may strengthen the other.


I cannot claim that every abstinence-oriented programme outperforms comprehensive education, or that consent teaching makes children sexually active. The available findings do not justify either claim. But the lack of long-term measures of fidelity or chastity does not prevent me from stating my own moral convictions clearly. It prevents me from passing those convictions off as experimentally proven outcomes.



A positive Christian understanding of freedom


Within traditional Christianity, chastity is not simply the absence of sexual activity before marriage. It is part of the discipline of the whole person: learning not to make desire our master, to regard another human being as someone to love rather than consume, and to accept that not everything possible or permitted is beneficial. That discipline does not end at the wedding ceremony.


The Orthodox Church in America's teaching on marriage speaks of sexual intimacy as belonging to the union, mutual strengthening and joy of husband and wife, as well as openness to children. It does not reduce marriage to reproduction. Nor does it turn marriage into a licence to demand sexual access. In 1 Corinthians 7, St Paul describes mutual responsibilities and agreement within marriage; the emphasis is reciprocal, not a one-sided entitlement.


The broader historic Christian understanding sees marriage as a faithful covenant between a man and a woman. Christians differ about some practical and pastoral questions, and individuals living outside that ideal do not possess less dignity. The value of a person is not measured by marital status, past conduct, sexual history or whether a particular struggle has been overcome.


I am not writing from a position of Christian moral superiority. Christianity begins with an honest recognition of human fallenness. We experience temptation, make mistakes and often struggle with desires we do not wish to entertain. The Christian response is not to pretend those struggles do not exist or to condemn people who seek help. Prayer, repentance, confession, humility and the gradual acquisition of self-control are part of learning how to live faithfully. Those same virtues are necessary within marriage, where patience and gentleness may matter most when desire is not shared.


Nor should chastity be reduced to a message addressed only to girls. Boys need to learn that strength does not consist of sexual conquest, that a refusal must be accepted without pressure, and that the dignity of another person outweighs their immediate desires. Girls need to know that attention, attraction or affection create no obligation to become sexually active. Both need adults who model fidelity and respectful boundaries rather than demanding virtues they refuse to practise.


To teach waiting positively is not to deny that young people experience attraction or curiosity. It is to tell them that feelings are real without being commands. Consent education rightly teaches them to refuse someone else's request; chastity also teaches that they may decline to follow their own desire. This may mean turning away from pornography, declining to share an intimate image, resisting peer pressure or deciding that a relationship should develop without sexual intimacy.


The capacity not to be mastered by desire is itself a form of freedom. The Christian understanding does not treat this as fear of the body, but as respect for the whole person, made in the image of God. We are learning to exercise agency well, not merely to claim permission for everything that is possible.



Who is entrusted with teaching the child?


Parents have the first and most enduring responsibility for forming children, but they cannot fulfil that responsibility by silence. If children are learning about sex from phones, peers and commercial content, adults cannot simply complain about the culture while avoiding difficult conversations at home.


Australian Christian sexologist Dr Patricia Weerakoon offers parents a practical example of how honest information and Christian conviction can belong in the same conversation. In her 2014 article Sex education and your tweens, she encourages parents to speak openly and without fear, to give children a secure sense of identity and to show through their own example that sexuality education concerns character, personal integrity and faithfulness, not only biology. In Talking to your teenage children about sex, she explicitly encourages families to explain why Christians reserve sexual intimacy for marriage, while teaching young people that they can say no and can approach their parents with difficult questions.


What I appreciate about that approach is its positive vision. Parents need not choose between giving their children accurate information about their bodies and teaching the worth of chastity, patience and faithful marriage. Christian formation cannot simply consist of prohibitions, either. The example we set, the way we treat our spouse and the willingness to listen when a child is troubled all matter. We must be prepared to model the very virtues we hope to pass on.


Churches, too, have responsibilities beyond repeating prohibitions. A community that teaches chastity must also protect children, challenge abusive conduct, respond compassionately to disclosures and hold adults accountable. It must offer a credible model of marriage as faithful, patient and sacrificial. Teaching about purity while concealing coercion would betray the very moral framework we claim to defend.


Teachers and public institutions carry a different responsibility. Their safeguarding role is real and necessary; not every child has a safe or informed home. They should provide accurate information about bodies, law, boundaries and available support. But public authority also requires transparency about the ethical judgments embedded in lessons. Which materials are used? Who developed them? At what age? What evidence supports their claims? Can parents see what is presented, and is reasonable disagreement treated respectfully?


These questions are not answered by assuming every educator shares a single agenda. South Australia says its current respectful-relationships work builds on the existing curriculum and involves consultation. The full assessment of materials, providers and funding belongs in the next part of this series. I am not alleging that a specific classroom lesson has deliberately promoted casual sex merely because it discusses consent.


I am asking for a positive contribution that ought to be possible even amid disagreement. Teach children that sexual activity is not a test of maturity or acceptance. Teach them that waiting is not failure, that another person's desire creates no entitlement, and that respecting another person's dignity may require forgoing something we want. And allow families to explain why their faith and conscience place intimacy within a lifelong covenant.


A child may one day choose a different moral path from the one parents have taught. That reality does not remove our responsibility to guide with love, nor justify coercion or humiliation. It makes the integrity of our example more important.



Beyond consent


In the first article, I examined why the law cannot make a child's apparent agreement the measure of an adult's conduct. This second inquiry turns to what adults ought to teach before those boundaries are tested. Consent education can convey necessary safeguards. Research on pornography raises serious questions about developing expectations and adult relationships. And the documents shaping education show that choices about what makes a relationship good cannot be separated entirely from moral judgment.


I have not established that Australian schools have abandoned restraint or that every young person encounters the same pressures. I have established a narrower point: one national framework explicitly addresses respectful relationships and sexual ethics without comparably commending chastity, postponement or marital fidelity. Australian survey responses show that some young people are waiting, including for reasons of readiness, love and marriage. Their choices deserve recognition as something more than a footnote to a discussion of permission.


I share the Howes' underlying conviction that fidelity, chastity and self-restraint need not be understood as outdated restrictions. They can be positive ways of loving another person. Christine Emba's work and the research on readiness show that the question reaches beyond a single Christian conversation: when we establish the conditions under which intimacy may occur, have we also offered a convincing account of why it should sometimes be reserved, restrained or declined altogether?


For me, the answer begins with a Christian understanding of the human person. Children are neither miniature adults nor future consumers to be prepared for an increasingly sexual marketplace. They are persons bearing God's image. They deserve protection from exploitation, patient moral guidance and adults prepared to exercise the very self-control they commend.


St Paul makes a distinction that I find particularly relevant here. Permission, in itself, cannot tell us whether an action is beneficial or whether we have become mastered by our own desires:


“All things are lawful unto me, but all things are not expedient: all things are lawful for me, but I will not be brought under the power of any.” — 1 Corinthians 6:12 (KJV)


I believe St Paul's distinction matters deeply for children. Consent is a necessary boundary, and chastity is a positive vision of how to live within it. Children need the freedom to refuse another person's demands, and the freedom not to obey every desire of their own. That is not a retreat from agency, but part of learning how to exercise it well.


The next article will ask a question this one cannot answer from national guidance alone: what is actually being taught in Australian classrooms? I will examine the curricula, resources, external providers, funding and parental safeguards through which educational ideas become school practice.


For now, I leave parents, educators and every adult entrusted with a child with a question: are we teaching children to say no only when someone crosses a boundary, or also to wait because some things are worth preserving?


Thanks for reading.

God Bless

Mark.


Scripture graphic quoting 1 Corinthians 6:12 (KJV) above an open Bible at sunrise over the Australian countryside, reflecting Christian freedom, wisdom and mastery over personal desires.

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating

COPYRIGHT - 2026 FAITH CULTURE POLITICS AUSTRALIA 

  • Youtube
  • Facebook
  • X
  • TikTok
bottom of page